|
Still
more details are emerging from the weekend bailout of
Citigroup. And in what is no surprise in this corner, it appears
Citigroup is not well capitalized and Faces Pressure to
Slim Down.
The
government rescue of Citigroup Inc. reversed the perilous slide of the
company's stock, but pressure is mounting on its executives and directors to
do even more to stabilize the financial giant.
Citigroup executives acknowledged Monday that the government made it clear in
weekend negotiations that it expects the company to continue to reduce its
appetite for risk, and to seriously weigh more drastic actions, including
possibly breaking up the company.
"This is a reprieve, but it's not a complete pardon," said another
person familiar with the matter, referring to the government rescue plan. "Nobody's
confused about that."
The company faces swelling losses on loans that aren't covered under the
government's loss-sharing agreement, which amounts to insurance on a $306
billion pool of assets. Under the plan, Citigroup will shoulder the first $29
billion in losses on that pool. After that, three government agencies will
absorb 90% of any remaining losses, which amounts to $249 billion.
The arrangement covers Citigroup's portfolios of U.S. residential and
commercial mortgages and its leveraged corporate loans, among other assets. The
assets aren't just risky ones; the government insisted that the agreement
cover entire asset classes, so that Citigroup couldn't simply dump toxic
loans and securities in the lap of taxpayers.
Absent from the arrangement are Citigroup's giant credit-card business, where
defaults have been rapidly piling up, and its overseas lending operations,
which also are showing signs of stress.
While the government deal bolsters Citigroup's capital ratios, "we are
concerned that losses may eventually exceed the government's backstop,"
said Standard & Poor's equity analyst Stuart Plesser.
In exchange for covering hundreds of billions of dollars in potential losses,
Citigroup is issuing the government a total of $27 billion in preferred
shares, in which the government will receive regular dividends. The
government now holds a 7.8% stake in Citigroup, which entitles it to $3.4
billion a year in dividends.
On Friday, Citigroup Vice Chairman Lewis Kaden and investment banker Edward
Kelly spoke by phone with New York Fed President Timothy Geithner to discuss
the worsening situation.
Inside the government it was far from clear that action was needed. Citigroup's
stock price was tumbling, but there was no sense the company was in danger of
failing. But over the weekend, as they pored through Citigroup's books, it
became clear to top officials that the company needed government help.
On Saturday morning, Citigroup executives sent a blueprint based on the
Wachovia structure to government officials.
Policymakers balked, thinking the plan too beneficial to Citigroup. If the U.S. were to take another equity stake, Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson wanted it to be
small, since otherwise the government would end up owning Citigroup. The
officials worried that appearing to nationalize the company would further
roil markets. They agreed that $20 billion was the limit for what they would
invest.
Not everyone was satisfied. FDIC Chairman Sheila Bair harbored reservations
about a bailout because it exposure her agency to big losses. She wanted
government officials to consider an arrangement that would be more punitive
to Citigroup shareholders. An FDIC spokesman said "limiting the
potential exposure of the deposit-insurance fund is always a high priority
for Chairman Bair."
On Sunday morning, the disagreement ignited a heated debate between Ms. Bair
and her counterparts at other agencies, say people familiar with the
discussions.
Around 6 p.m. on Sunday, Mr. Paulson called Ms. Bair to talk to her
privately. He told her helping Citigroup was important and that if she
couldn't play a meaningful role, the Fed and Treasury could do it without
her.
Ms. Bair agreed to be involved but would only accept the FDIC taking $10
billion of the losses, with the Fed guaranteeing most of the rest.
The question now is
"Just how bad are Citigroup's books?" Don't expect answers from the
Fed, but when FDIC Chairman Sheila Bair wants no part of the action, we at
least have an indirect answer: Things at Citigroup (and no doubt everywhere
else), are not as good as the financial institutions are letting on.
Viability Of Banking System In Question
"You have to think before it's over that other banks will have to
come with similar deals. Others will be begging for the same terms that
Citigroup got."
Click Here To Play
Video
All US Financials Will be Nationalized in a Year
Hugh Hendry, chief investment officer at hedge fund Eclectica Asset
Management, said Friday All US Financials Will be Nationalized in a
Year.
It's
not preferable, but all major U.S. financial companies will eventually be
under government control because the alternative is so much worse. "All
financials will be owned by the U.S. government in a year," Hendry said.
"I bet you."
Nationalizations take dramatic losses from the private sector and places them
on the larger balance sheet of the public sector, he said. "It's not
good," but society is vulnerable and society is going to have to
intervene, Hendry said.
Shareholders Should Get Nothing
Because the taxpayers are forced to foot the bill for bailout out the banks,
shareholders shouldn't be compensated, Hendry added.
anking System Is
Insolvent
The US banking system is insolvent. I can easily add to the list compiled on
July 23, 2008, but here is point 25 on You Know The
Banking System Is Unsound When....
25. Of
the $6.84 Trillion in bank deposits, the total cash on hand at banks is a
mere $273.7 Billion. Where is the rest of the loot? The answer is in off
balance sheet SIVs, imploding commercial real estate deals, Alt-A liar loans,
Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac bonds, toggle bonds where debt is amazingly paid
back with more debt, and all sorts of other silly (and arguably fraudulent)
financial wizardry schemes that have bank and brokerage firms leveraged at
30-1 or more. Those
loans cannot be paid back.
Note: The H8 Report for the week ending
November 12, Assets and Liabilities of Commercial Banks in the United States not seasonally adjusted, page 2, shows 7.141 trillion in deposits and cash
assets of $873.1 billion. Cash on hand started soaring in October along with
the TARP bailout plan and other swap options. That's still nowhere near enough cash.
Mish
GlobalEconomicAnalysis.blogspot.com
Mish's Global Economic
Trend Analysis
Thoughts on the great inflation/deflation/stagflation
debate as well as discussions on gold, silver, currencies, interest rates,
and policy decisions that affect the global markets.
| |