|
Edward
Hugh at Euro Watch is asking From A Greek Debt
Crisis To A Eurozone Structural One?
When
we look back five years from now, will we see this week as marking a turning
point in the short, but far from uneventful, ten year history of
Europe’s common currency?
Simon Derrick, chief currency strategist at Bank of New York Mellon even went
so far as to say the trauma of recent days might well signal the point that
we stop talking about
a “Greek debt crisis” and start talking about a “Eurozone
structural crisis” .
Basically it is important to recognise that the current crisis has placed the
spotlight on the severe institutional weaknesses which lie underpin the
common currency, and it is just these weaknesses which are leading so many
commentators to now ask themselves whether it might not have been easier to
implement political union in Europe before embarking on such an ambitious
monetary experiment.
These weaknesses became even more clear on Thursday when Jean Claude Trichet
went very public in making clear that he personally is
totally opposed to IMF participation in any Greece "rescue".
The Economist magazine
have done their own calculation on this, and
they estimate that a loan of €75 billion rather than the currently
rumoured €25 billion will be needed and that the country is likely to
need five years (rather than three) to get its deficit down below 3% of GDP.
They also assume that Greek GDP will be 5% below its current level by 2014.
Obviously the output you get in these sort of calculations rather depend on
the expectations you put in, but these are not unrealistic expectations.
The bottom line is that there is no easy answer here, and Europe is
struggling to convince the rest of the world that it has both the will and
the instruments to effectively tackle the problem of maintaining a single
currency in a diverse group of countries. Herman Van Rompuy
said on Friday there was no danger of Portugal being sucked into the same
sort of debt whirlpool as Greece, and that
Portugal would not be the next country to be sent over to Washington in
search of a helping technical hand from the IMF. Which raises the question:
if it won't be Portugal, who will it be?
Spain's
Economic Woes
The Economist is discussing Spain and The Mañana
Syndrome
The
list of things that need repair is extensive. Spain’s structural faults
were long hidden by a housing bubble and have been glaringly exposed now that
it has burst. From unemployment and low productivity growth, and from
troubled savings banks to creaky public finances, the problems are piling up.
With the government unwilling to apply radical surgery, there are fears that
Spain will fall further behind its neighbours. “The risk is that we
will have a lost decade, like Portugal or Japan,” says Lorenzo Bernaldo
de Quirós, an economist at Freemarket International Consulting in
Madrid.
Unemployment tops most people’s worries. Faster growth is needed to
bring it down. Yet Spain has been in recession for seven quarters; the
government expects GDP to shrink again this year; and the IMF forecasts
growth of less than 1% in 2011.
The public finances must also be fixed. Last year’s deficit ballooned
to over 11% of GDP. In January Elena Salgado, the finance minister, produced
an outline of austerity measures that calmed market fears about Spanish debt.
But two months later the plan still lacks detail—and has an obvious
flaw. An optimistic Ms Salgado predicted growth of 3% in both 2012 and 2013,
bringing added revenues to cut the deficit. Spain’s European
commissioner, Joaquín Almunia, has warned against the sin of
over-optimism. Growth will not go over 2% until 2014, says Ángel
Laborda, an economist at FUNCAS, the savings banks’ foundation. He
reckons that more tax rises and spending cuts are inevitable if the
government is to hit its 3% deficit target by 2013.
The Bank of Spain’s governor, Miguel Ángel Fernández
Ordóñez, is calling for reform of a rigid labour market that
makes most employees too costly to fire but condemns a third of workers to
unstable, unprotected temporary jobs. Yet the government has repeatedly
delayed pension and labour reforms. Mr Zapatero’s great goal is to
conserve social peace. That means keeping trade unions happy, even if reforms
(and growth) have to wait.
Some detect a whiff of cowardice. Mr Zapatero’s determination to avoid
general strikes is proof that he will never take a difficult decision, says
Artur Mas, head of the Catalan Convergence and Union coalition. And because
broad agreements on public-spending cuts lack detail, they also lack urgency.
The delay in sorting out the cajas adds to the sense of drift. Most Spaniards
do not see the economy improving any time soon. Faith in the political class
is at rock bottom. The Spanish now rate politicians as a bigger problem than
their old bugbear, terrorism. Mr Zapatero’s Socialists are trailing in
the polls—but an election is not due for two more years.
UK
Pain To Come
The British Economy has Pain To Come.
As
Britain prepares to go to the polls, its sick economy is uppermost in
voters’ minds. With good reason. There are fundamental doubts that it
can ever recover fully from a banking crisis and recession that laid Britain
lower than many other rich countries. In the short term, the worry is whether
a feeble recovery reliant on fiscal and monetary life-support can develop its
own driving force.
The economy shrank by 5% last year, the biggest fall since the Great
Depression. The contraction over the six quarters of the recession was 6.2%.
That peak-to-trough decline was less severe than in Japan, Germany and Italy,
but the recession lasted longer than in any other G7 economy.
The public finances look even worse. Not only is the budget deficit the
highest, as a proportion of GDP, since the second world war, but this
year’s will be the biggest of any G7 (and even G20) economy, according
to the IMF. The build-up in government debt between 2007 and 2014 will be
second only to Japan’s (see chart 1).
Recent disappointing export performance has dimmed hopes that Britain can
trade its way out of the quagmire.
As one reverse has followed another, Britain’s economic reputation has
nosedived. So has sterling. Its trade-weighted value has fallen by around a
quarter since mid-2007, a bigger decline even than after the pound was turfed
out of the European exchange-rate mechanism in 1992. For some, Britain now
vies with the distressed likes of Greece and Spain for the title of sick man
of Europe.
There is also more than a passing resemblance to Japan, which never regained
its economic stride after its banking crisis of the 1990s. Could Britain now
follow suit, given that its financial system came so close to collapse in
October 2008? Those inclined to think so find worrying confirmation in a
report by McKinsey, a management consultancy, which shows that total indebtedness
in the British economy was the highest as a share of GDP among ten advanced
countries in 2008, narrowly beating Japan’s.
Britain’s political economy is on trial as much as its economy. The
government is currently spending four pounds for every three it receives in
revenues. This reflects not just the severity of the recession but
misjudgments during the good years. It was a mistake to be borrowing at all,
let alone over 2% of GDP, in 2006 and 2007 when the economy was strong.
Moreover, that deficit would have been even higher but for inflated receipts
from ebullient property markets and financial firms.
Mr Darling’s budget is the last breath of a dying government. What will
really count is the first one of the next parliament. That budget will have
to do what the chancellor failed to do: set out a credible plan for reducing
the deficit, grounded in sober rather than wishful forecasts for growth,
decide where spending cuts will actually be made, and also—in all
probability—announce additional tax increases.
The country’s economic future may be less dazzling than before but that
glitter turned out to be fool’s gold. After those excesses, a period of
private sobriety and public austerity may prove to be no bad thing.
There
is much more to see in Economist articles on Spain and the UK. Please give
them a look.
Deflation Persists In Japan
Bloomberg is reporting Japan Deflation
Persists as Consumer Prices Fall 1.2%
Japan’s
consumer prices fell for a 12th month in February, adding pressure on the
central bank to eradicate deflation that is hampering the economic recovery.
Prices excluding fresh food slid 1.2 percent from a year earlier, after
dropping a 1.3 percent in each of the preceding two months, the statistics
bureau said today in Tokyo.
Finance Minister Naoto Kan said the report shows more efforts are needed to
overcome deflation even as price declines ease.
Because of Japan’s record public debt, “the scope for fiscal
stimulus is very, very limited to non-existent, but there’s probably
more scope on the monetary side,” said John Praveen, chief investment
strategist at Prudential International Investments Advisers LLC, a unit of
Prudential Financial Inc., which manages $667 billion. BOJ liquidity
injections will support the economy and stock market even as deflation
persists, he said on Bloomberg Television.
What does Japan
have to show for two years of fighting deflation?
This:
With credit once again to the Economist.
Japan's 2014 estimated 246% ratio of debt to GDP exceeds every other G7
country by a mile.
Take a look at the problems in Spain, Japan, Greece, Italy, and the UK. Even
Canada does not look so hot as noted in California USA vs.
Ontario Canada - Which State (Province) Is In Worse Shape?
Moreover, Canada, Australia, the UK, and China all have huge property bubbles
that have yet to pop, but they will.
The US is certainly not alone in fiscal problems. Indeed, global imbalances
mount as governments all over the globe sing the praises of the nascent
recovery. Unfortunately there is no recovery, only a mirage of ever mounting
debt.
Mish
GlobalEconomicAnalysis.blogspot.com
To
sign up for a free copy of Sitka’s Monthly Client Newsletter,
please register your email address at the bottom of the Sitka Pacific Commentary Page.
Mish's Global Economic Trend Analysis
Thoughts
on the great inflation/deflation/stagflation debate as well as discussions on
gold, silver, currencies, interest rates, and policy decisions that affect
the global markets.
|
|