This month's calendar has been
chock a block with one important meeting or vote or conference after another.
Any one of these could have had a large impact on the endless Euro crisis.
The most impressive result (sarcasm implied) from all these meetings and
votes is the overall lack of impact. For all the wild swings in both debt and
equity markets things have changed little in the past month and the European muddle
through continues.
Greece has a new, pro-bailout,
government with three coalition partners. The election turned out better than
feared but the real work lies ahead. All of the parties in the election
promised a much looser austerity program either through negotiation or simply
by reneging on the deal. The winning coalition promised Greeks they could
have their baklava and eat it too, to a lesser extent. Based on probably
accurate leaks out of Athens the plan is to approach EU institutions looking
for a two year extension to hit deficit targets. This would require about $20
billion in additional loans above the two Greek bailout packages in place
already.
This news is not going over
well in Berlin. Greeks took comments about trying to work with a pro bailout
government to mean there would be some sort of completely new deal. Not
likely. The Greek government has zero fiscal credibility, particularly since
the winning party that dominates the cabinet is exactly the same one that had
the biggest hand in creating the problem. Most Europeans, but particularly
Germans, simply do not and will not believe Greece will stick to any deal.
German Chancellor Merkel is
being vilified for being such a hardliner but she lives in a democracy and
poll after poll shows German's hate the idea of lending money that cannot be
policed later. This is the core issue for the EU and has been since its
inception. Most member governments are unwilling to give up any real fiscal
sovereignty. This means that lender states have little or no control over
what happens to their funds after the cheque is cashed. It was no secret this
was a big problem when the EU was being created. Intricate rules and
prohibitions were laid down that were meant to keep member countries on
roughly the same plane when it came to deficit levels, etc.
Of course, these rules were
broken by virtually every member state, including Germany itself. So many EU
countries breached the maximum deficit level as a percentage of GDP rules
that it's hardly surprising these rules are now viewed as mere suggestions.
This mess would always have
taken years to work through. The timeline is now longer, if anything. That is
partially due to the multi-year contraction in most of the debtor economies.
Even with harsh cuts it will take more time to balance budgets and there is
no likelihood of surpluses that can reduce debt loads until debtor economies
actually start growing again.
This news hasn't gone over
well with creditor nations. An understandable reaction since a long timeline
inevitably means more loans to some of the debtor nations. Nonetheless, it's
becoming obvious that the creditors are not going to get a one way deal here.
There is going to have to be some compromise before this drama ends. Unless
creditor countries are willing to sweeten things, if only to improve
sentiment in the peripheral countries, it will be hard for debtor economies
to pull out of their tailspins.
Current hopes rest with the EU
meeting that is currently taking place. This is the eighteenth meeting
since the crisis erupted which should tell us what the chances of success
are. The most important topic is some sort of EU level bank oversight and
deposit insurance. This will take years to create but even putting together
credible time line and laying out what sort of bank oversight is being worked
towards will help.
As we have noted many times,
the current danger point is Spain and it's the victim of a real estate
bubble, not bad governance per se. As this issue was being finished there was
news of a compromise that will help the Spanish sovereign bond market. The EU
has agreed that the latest loan package will not have preference. This is
significant since it could and should give buyers of Spanish sovereigns more
comfort since it will not place 100 billion euros of debt ahead of them if
something goes wrong.
Italy's government is more
guilty of pure mismanagement but it matters not; the EU does not want to see
the Italian bond market go south. It's just too big to fix. Many of the
leading banks are also too big for their home countries to deal with. Ireland
and Iceland are the poster children for too big to fail banks (though, in
retrospect, both countries probably should have let them fail anyway) but
many other countries have banks that represent systemic risk, including
Germany.
Bank oversight is not a
bailout so much as something obvious and sensible that should have been put
in place the day the Euro was created. Promising not to demand preference for
the current loan package to Spain is a huge relief to the market but the most
important part of the compromise is the promise to set up an EU banking
authority.
In typical EU fashion the
details on the banking authority were scant and the timelines will
undoubtedly be longer than the market wants but it's a big step in the right
direction. One of the chief problems in Europe is the direct ties between
bank recapitalization and sovereign debt levels. Up to now, whenever a
country that could not recapitalize its banks went to the EU the money would
have to be borrowed and distributed by the government. If this new
bank authority is able to lend directly to financial institutions then every
bank recapitalization will not automatically result in an equal increase it
the home country's sovereign debt level.
That is a huge change if the
EU actually pulls this off. That said, this is Europe we're talking about.
There will be lots of meetings and position papers and bureaucratic wrangling
involved before the details are agreed to. There is still room for things to
go pear shaped if Germany and other creditor nations impose conditions so
harsh that they cancel out the positive effects. That possibility could cap
gains but this does feel like a real shift in the political landscape. The
arrival of a large anti-austerity block headed by French President Hollande
has changed the equation.
The Euro crisis is not over.
Germany and its austerity block allies have yielded on a couple of important
points but don't expect a complete about face. There shouldn't be one because
Merrkel and her allies are right. The only long term solution is lower debt
levels and structural changes to economies that make them more flexible and
responsive to changing conditions. The former is going to take years to
accomplish even under best case scenarios. The latter may too since
confronting entrenched interest groups takes more political courage than most
Euro area leaders seem to possess.
Expect more turbulence in the
Euro market. Battle lines have been drawn between the pro and anti-austerity
camps and there are many more fights ahead. The debt crisis and uncertainty
about how to navigate it has done enormous economic damage to the Eurozone
that will take a long time to repair. Even mighty Germany has put out recent
economic readings that imply it is starting to stall. That may well be the
real reason Merkel finally showed some flexibility. It would have been better
by far if this had happened two or three years ago.
Hopefully this does not
embolden the anti-austerity group to the point where they forget cost cutting
and reforms are still a necessity. French President's Hollande's renewed
promise to lower the retirement age in France was not a positive sign. Aside
from being just plain stupid under current economic conditions it's also
exactly the kind of grandstanding that could stiffen the resolve of creditor
governments and mess up further progress.
Economic readings outside of
the Euro area have mainly come in better than expected. Not great, but good
enough to add some pressure to the Euro on top of its internal issues.
Announcement of the compromise deal is generating one the largest one day
move in the Euro this year. Gold has been trading with a very high positive
correlation to the Euro so it's getting plenty of lift too and the entire
commodity complex is following suit. This is all to the good but traders can
be forgiven for remaining somewhat cautious. When it comes to Europe this is
a movie we have all seen may times before. The devil is in the details when
it comes to multi-lateral agreements. EU rescue funds still don't and won't
have enough money to literally rescue Italy for instance. It's unlikely it
every will so the key will be regaining and retaining investor confidence.
The EU must get bond traders on side and keep them there. If they can do that
the world economy should be able to muddle through.
Even with that the summer
doldrums won't provide a lot of trading opportunities unless and until
another company makes what looks like a major find. Volumes will climb only
slowly but continued movement in the right direction politically in Europe
may finally give us a set up for a meaningful fall rally in the resource
sector. Let's all cross our virtual fingers and hope the Eurocrats don't find
yet another creative way to wrest defeat from the jaws of victory.
